Kirk Pennality murder box not affected by the grace of the widow: Expert

A high -level legal expert and a retired navy jag threw cold water on the assertions that Erika Kirk’s “pardon” and the “forgiveness” of Charlie Kirk’s murder, Tyler Robinson, is a defense boon in his probable quest to avoid a case of death.

Cully Stimson, assistant director of Edwin Meese Center for Legal and Judicial Studies de la Heritage Foundation and the former head of the administration George W. Bush, said that observers should not confuse “thanks to Erika Kirk as a religious person” with the erosion of legal responsibility.

“Because it had the strength of the character and the will to forgive as a Christian does not automatically have the incitement, namely if the state can and should continue the ultimate punishment – and if the state and will obtain a judgment including the ultimate punishment,” said Stimson.

The Ministry of Justice asked to request the death penalty in the capital of the murders of the Jewish museum

Erika Kirk is emotional during a commemorative service for her husband, the conservative commentator killed Charlie Kirk, at the State Farm Stadium in Arizona, September 21, 2025. (Reuters / Carlos Barria)

As a former prosecutor and defense lawyer, Stimson said he could consider the case going to the trial – but suggested that it could not – and when he will do it, the defense showed a case pointing to the comment of Erika Kirk.

“Listen, even the wife of the deceased has forgiven our client, and therefore there is really no reason to go ahead with the death penalty,” said Stimson La Défense.

The state of Utah could then agree and abandon the capital punishment as a potential result, or reject the concept of the defense from the start.

The case is not kirk v. (Suspect), this is the state of Utah v. (Suspect), he noted, noting that the state as a proxy therefore has even more lever to bring the ultimate punishment against the suspect, whatever the way the defense can translate the comments of the Kirk family.

Stimson underlined the cases of rape he tried when the victim knew the suspect, manifests himself, accusations are pressed, evidence is presented – but when the suspect is condemned, the victim suddenly does not want a prolonged or severe sanction – whether for personal, religious or other reasons.

Utah prosecutors are preparing a potential case of death penalty against the suspect of Charlie Kirk Tyler James Robinson

“In general, the laws on the rights of the victims of the state require that the government-here, the prosecutor, takes into account the opinions of the victims or members of the family of victims. This does not mean that they must follow them,” he said.

The case also brought back the scenarios of the unique death penalty of Utah.

Utah – with Idaho, Mississippi, Oklahoma, in South Carolina – always authorizes the shooting as a method of execution. Until 1996, some states also authorized the suspension – the murderer of Delaware Billy Bailey being the last condemned of this type to meet this end.

Stimson rejected criticism from a shooting team as an unusual or unusual unconstitution, and also rejected the affirmations that the death penalty itself is reversed.

The retired FBI agent warns against “assassination culture” after learning that Kirk Suspect lived with Transner

“The death penalty is mentioned three times in the Constitution … The death penalty has been held constitutional since 1976.”

He said that the shooting would respect the eighth amendment in that it is not cruel – because the condemned person dies instantly – and not unusual.

However, other methods of execution such as the electric chair, which are almost aimless today, were more common but at the same time less in accordance with the eighth amendment, Stimson said that criticisms could in turn say.

Click here to download the Fox News app

The electric chair has not always led to instant and instantaneous death, and the method may have been considered unusual in its construction, he suggested.

The army, he said, always has the shooting team as a method of execution on his books, said the retired Jag officer, although the Pentagon has not executed anyone from the PVT. John Bennett was hanged at Fort Leavenworth for rape in 1916.